Digital Media Center
Bryant-Denny Stadium, Gate 61
920 Paul Bryant Drive
Tuscaloosa, AL 35487-0370
(800) 654-4262

© 2023 Alabama Public Radio
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
WAPR is operating at limited power. Thank you for your patience while we look into the issue.

"1865 Alabama: From Civil War to Uncivil Peace" By: Christopher Lyle McIlwain, Sr.

“1865 Alabama: From Civil War to Uncivil Peace”

Author: Christopher Lyle McIlwain, Sr.   

Publisher: University of Alabama Press  

Pages: 276

Price: $59.95 (Cloth)

Christopher McIlwain, a practicing Tuscaloosa attorney, has been researching Alabama in the Civil War for over 25 years.

He has gone deeply into such primary sources as letters, diaries, drafts of legislation before the Alabama legislature and, especially, the editorial pages of the many Alabama newspapers during the years 1861-1865.

The result has been two books. "Civil War Alabama" focused on the ways in which Alabama was not united in its desire for secession and in its desire to maintain slavery.

Small landholders with no slaves were reluctant to be the poor men who would fight the rich man's war. Many North Alabamians held strong Unionist sympathies; and there were even Alabama cavalry units in the Union Army.

But the influence of the planters, reinforced by states' rights rhetoric and the misuse of scripture, prevailed, and four years of slaughter and destruction followed.

In this book, McIlwain focuses on the last of those four years, 1865. 

Richmond fell on April 1.

Lee surrendered his army on April 9.

Further resistance was futile and almost everybody in Alabama knew it. Alabama might have sued for a separate peace, preventing the destructive raids on Tuscaloosa and Selma. The railroads and industry of Alabama would have been mostly intact for postwar development.

Unfortunately, Alabama firebrands such as John Forsyth of the “Mobile Advertiser and Register” were not having it. His editorials were incendiary; any talk of compromise was treason to The Cause.

Winston Churchill is much admired for his wartime speech insisting that the British would fight on the beaches, in streets, and in the fields, and would never surrender. Fortunately for all, the British won.

Alabamians, spurning any peace offers at the February Hampton Roads Peace Conference, vowing to fight to the last man, to the last drop of blood, and then to fight in guerrilla bands and even possibly carry on the fight from across the Mexican border, gave ammunition to the radical Republicans and the die-hard abolitionists. 

Needless to say, talk of never-ending conflict discouraged badly needed Northern capital investment in the South. 

It was understood that Lincoln meant to impose a rather gentle reconstruction, "with malice toward none; with charity for all."

Confederates would almost all be pardoned.

Lincoln's plan might not have included Negro suffrage, and, despite the Emancipation Proclamation, there was even the possibility of a phasing out of slavery through apprenticeship programs.

When Abraham Lincoln was assassinated in April, in a plot very likely hatched in Mobile, the South should have gone into mourning. Instead, “The Demopolis Herald” headline read "Glorious News." 

Now, nothing but complete destruction of the South's ability to wage war would do. 

The “New York Times” called for "a 'class revolution' in the South that would 'grind' the Southern aristocracy to powder." There should be executions of Rebel leaders, with most Confederates disqualified from any future political office, immediate, uncompensated abolition and Negro suffrage, and an army of occupation to see that Federal law was obeyed and no Resistance sprang up.

McIlwain ends his study with a page of what-ifs, roads not taken. The Reconstruction/occupation was harsher than it would have been under Lincoln. The economy, industry, race relations, public safety were all much worse than they needed to be.

For over one hundred years Alabama suffered as a result of its own stubbornness, terrible leadership and intransigence.

It didn't have to be this way. 

Don Noble is host of the Alabama Public Television literary interview show “Bookmark with Don Noble.” His most recent book is Belles’ Letters 2, a collection of short fiction by Alabama women.

Don Noble , Ph. D. Chapel Hill, Prof of English, Emeritus, taught American literature at UA for 32 years. He has been the host of the APTV literary interview show "Bookmark" since 1988 and has broadcast a weekly book review for APR since November of 2001, so far about 850 reviews. Noble is the editor of four anthologies of Alabama fiction and the winner of the Alabama state prizes for literary scholarship, service to the humanities and the Governor's Arts Award.
News from Alabama Public Radio is a public service in association with the University of Alabama. We depend on your help to keep our programming on the air and online. Please consider supporting the news you rely on with a donation today. Every contribution, no matter the size, propels our vital coverage. Thank you.