Cutting-Edge Research Shows How Hair Dulls Razor Blades

Aug 6, 2020
Originally published on August 6, 2020 3:11 pm

A steel razor blade can get dull surprisingly quickly when cutting something as soft as hair, and now researchers have gotten their first up-close look at how a close shave actually damages an everyday disposable razor.

This leading-edge research, described in the journal Science, used a scanning electron microscope to peer at a razor as it sliced through strands of hair.

It found that, under the right conditions, a hair can produce tiny chips in the blade. That was unexpected, says Cemal Cem Tasan, a professor of metallurgy at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

An experimental setup is used to perform hair-cutting experiments inside a scanning electron microscope in the Tasan Group lab at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2019.
Gianluca Roscioli

"We know that blades fail after a number of uses. And, you know, you sort of take it for granted, you feel that it is normal," Tasan says. But given that the steel used for razors is extremely hard, he points out, it's not clear why this should be so.

"For me, personally, it was both a scientific curiosity, of 'What's going on?' and also aiming to solve an important engineering problem," Tasan says.

He worked with two collaborators in his lab, graduate student Gianluca Roscioli and researcher Seyedeh Mohadeseh Taheri-Mousavi, to study methodically what happened to razor blades as they were used to shave again and again.

First, Roscioli purchased several brands of disposable razors. All of the blades were similar in terms of composition, he says. Under the powerful microscope, it was clear that the apparently smooth sharp edges had a jagged roughness.

Every three days, Roscioli would use the razors to shave his own facial hair. He would then peer at them using the microscope again, to track the changes to each blade over time.

The scientists were expecting that the tip of the blade would gradually become shorter and rounder as repeated use wore it down. "We found out that, although that occurs, the rate at which it occurs is very low," Roscioli says.

What happened more frequently was appearance of chips and fractures invisible to the naked eye. "The size of the chips are about 1/10 of the diameter of a human hair," Roscioli says. "The more I shaved, the more chips started appearing on the blade."

To see how soft hairs could trigger this chipping, he created a setup that let him use the microscope to watch a razor blade as it cut through one or more strands. He had to arrange it so that the hair could bend in a natural way that mimicked what happens during real shaving. He used both his own hair and the hair of colleagues, so that he could see the effect of different diameters.

It turns out that the angle of the blade and the hair's interaction are important. Unfortunately, just knowing that wouldn't help people shave in ways that would prevent chipping, says Tasan, who explains that people's hair tends to grow in different directions, so it's just inevitable that some hairs will hit the blade in ways that could chip it.

In addition, minuscule cracks are already present in an unused razor blade. Another important factor turned out to be where the hair is pushing on the blade in relationship to those existing cracks.

"If these micro-cracks are positioned just at the edge of the hair that's being cut, these cracks propagated more easily," says Tasan, who adds that this is also difficult to control.

Another thing that contributed to cracking and chipping is differences within the blade — if there are zones within the metal that are slightly harder or slightly softer. That might be easier to try to control, Tasan says, by coming up with steel that is as hard as today's razors but has a more uniform internal structure. The group has already filed a provisional patent on a process that could do that.

The researchers' findings have intrigued other scientists interested in blades and metals.

"I've been shaving since I was 13, and it's a pain," says Suveen Mathaudhu, a materials scientist at the University of California, Riverside. "I've always wondered what made the blades dull from cutting hair and how to best shave and take care of my own face."

These results make sense to him. "It's a good finding that when the hair bends, or the blade interacts with the hair at a certain angle, it can cause chipping," says Mathaudhu, who notes he thought that corrosion would have played more of a role, given that shaving blades are exposed to water.

Jennifer Carter, a researcher at Case Western Reserve University, described the new work as "beautiful" and that getting these microscope images was "not a trivial thing."

Still, she notes that this was a controlled experiment and that other factors might contribute to dulling of a razor blade in the real world.

"I would have said it has to do with the fact that my spouse drops it on the counter," she says.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

STACEY VANEK SMITH, HOST:

Now for some truly cutting-edge research on razors. Disposable razor blades can get dull very quickly. Turns out something as soft as hair takes a toll on stainless steel, and researchers got an up-close look at how. NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce reports.

NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: Gianluca Roscioli is a graduate student at MIT. Not too long ago, he bought some everyday drugstore razors and used a powerful scanning electron microscope to get images of each blades' edge. Then he used the razors to repeatedly shave his own face.

GIANLUCA ROSCIOLI: The way I did it was, first, imaging the entire blade. Then, every three days old, the beard, I shave it and image the blade. And after three days, shave again, image the blade, and so on.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He and his colleagues expected to see a gradual rounding of the blade's tip. That did happen - very slowly. What happened immediately was something completely different.

ROSCIOLI: The more I shaved, the more chips started appearing on the blade.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: These chips were teeny-tiny.

ROSCIOLI: The size of the chips are about one-tenth of the diameter of human hair. So they are not visible by human eye.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: It wasn't clear how soft hairs could trigger this chipping, so he set up an experiment that let him use the microscope to watch a razor blade as it cut through strands of hair. The results are in the journal Science. Cem Tasan is head of this MIT lab. He says the angle at which the blade meets the hair turns out to be really important. But knowing that won't help you make your razor last longer.

CEM TASAN: If you're shaving, obviously your hair is looking in different directions. And as the blade cuts through them, it's difficult to control in each case of what this angle is.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Tasan says another thing that mattered was where the hair was in relation to little micro-cracks found in all blades, even unused ones.

TASAN: If these micro-cracks are positioned just at the edge of the hair that's being cut, these cracks propagated more easily.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Again, that's impossible to control in the real world, but Tasan says their research does point to ways of reducing this chipping, like coming up with blades that have a more uniform internal structure. Suveen Mathaudhu is a material scientist at the University of California, Riverside, who wasn't part of the research team.

SUVEEN MATHAUDHU: I've been shaving since I was 13, and it's a pain.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He thought corrosion from water would play more of a role in dulling a razor.

MATHAUDHU: But it does make sense that at the very edge of a thin blade, if it's hard, that the conditions of bending of the hair and the conditions of the angle of interaction of the blade could cause chipping.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He says after thousands of years of making cutting tools, people are still learning how to produce the perfect blade for a job. Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.