Why The Last 'Wild' Horses Really Aren't

Feb 22, 2018
Originally published on February 23, 2018 6:57 am

A Mongolian horse that has long been hailed as the last truly wild horse species in existence isn't really all that wild.

It turns out that Przewalski's horses are actually feral descendants of the first horses that humans are known to have domesticated, around 5,500 years ago.

What's more, the modern horses that people ride today cannot be traced to those early steeds. That means humans must have tamed wild horses once again later on, somewhere else, but no one knows where or when.

These are the startling conclusions of a new genetic study, published in the journal Science, which challenges long-held assumptions about the entwined history of horses and humanity.

"It's huge. It changes fundamentally how we think about this. This kind of game-changing research is very rare," says Robin Bendrey, an archaeologist at the University of Edinburgh who has studied the domestication of horses but was not part of the research team. "It's incredibly exciting."

After all, Bendrey notes, "the domestication of the horse is very significant for the human past, for our ability to travel, communicate, and fight each other."

Ludovic Orlando, a researcher at the University of Toulouse in France, says that he and his colleagues set out to trace how the horse evolved after it was first domesticated.

They analyzed 88 ancient and modern horse genomes that span the last five millennia, including 20 horses from the Botai settlements in northern Kazakhstan.

That's where archaeologists have uncovered the earliest evidence of humans living with tame horses, such as corrals, remnants of horse milk on pottery, and patterns of tooth wear that suggest the animals wore harnesses.

While the researchers had assumed that the Botai horses would be the ancestors of modern domesticated horses, that's not what they found.

"Instead, we found that they are the ancestors of what we call today the 'wild horses,' " says Orlando.

It looks like the Botai culture's use of horses petered out to a dead end, as the horses somehow became untethered from humans and produced the feral descendants known today as Przewalski's horses, which are commonly described as the only wild horses left in the world.

"The first time we saw this result, none of us could believe it. It was that surprising — this is like turning upside [down] all the theories," says Orlando. "We spent a full year trying to kill the evidence we see, and we are very confident that the evidence we see is extremely robust."

Although the Botai culture has the first known evidence of horse domestication, archaeologists have puzzled over a gap of about 1,000 years after that before domesticated horses began to suddenly show up more regularly in the archaeological record, when things like chariots and harness fittings appeared and spread rapidly across Eurasia.

"This research helps explain something that's troubled people for a while," says Bendrey, noting that this pattern would make a lot more sense if there were separate domestication events, first by the Botai and then later somewhere else.

Now scientists are on a quest to figure out where, and to learn which population of historic horses gave rise to the modern-day ones that we're all so familiar with, says Sandra Olsen, an archaeologist at the University of Kansas, who has done work in Botai villages.

"We scientists are a bit sad because we feel that a bit of biodiversity has been lost, in that there are no more wild horses," says Olsen. "But the reality is, they disappeared some time ago."

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.


The idea of a wild horse - it's so romantic. Right? I mean, it's inspired art. It's inspired songs like this one...


ROLLING STONES: (Singing) Wild horses couldn't drag me away.

GREENE: ...And this one.


U2: (Singing) Who's going to ride your wild horses?

GREENE: Well, now science tells us that no one will ride your wild horses. And they also can't drag you away because they no longer exist. Here's NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce.

NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: Sometimes people call the mustangs out in the American West wild horses. But scientists would say they're feral - descendants of tame horses that went AWOL. In terms of truly wild horses, it's long been thought that there's just one remaining subspecies, a stocky Mongolian horse called Przewalski's horse.

LUDOVIC ORLANDO: If we call them wild, this is because we were thinking - we being all the researchers - we were thinking that they never had being domesticated.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: That's Ludovic Orlando of the University of Toulouse in France. He and some colleagues recently analyzed DNA from 88 horses, some modern ones but also dozens of ancient ones from remains and archaeological sites that date back over 5,000 years. What they found is described in the journal Science, and it's a shocker. It looks like the famous Przewalski's horse is actually feral. The Mongolian horses seem to be the descendants of horses from the Botai culture in northern Kazakhstan, which has the earliest recorded evidence of horse domestication.

ORLANDO: So basically, we found that the earliest domestic horses on the planet have survived today but not in the domesticated form but actually in what we call the wild horses.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: What's more, the horses that you might see out at your local barn do not seem to have descended from the Botai horses as scientists had assumed. So humans must have tamed horses again at some later point somewhere else.

ROBIN BENDREY: My immediate gut reaction is that the results of this paper is just huge. It's incredibly exciting.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: That's Robin Bendrey, an archaeologist at The University of Edinburgh. He says learning to use horses transformed human history. It changed how people traveled, communicated, fought wars.

BENDREY: So the actual story of when and where it happened is very important for the human past, and it's entwined with so many other things.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: That actual story is what scientists are trying to track down now.

Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News.


AMERICA: (Singing) You see, I been through the desert on a horse with no name. It felt good... Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.